Is there a fate worse than death?

We recently held our biggest fundraiser to date - 219: The Show (a big thanks to those of you who donated and attended). While the money we raised was fantastic, there was a bigger message behind the event that I hope everyone understood by the time they left.

The message: 219 pets a day die in Atlanta area shelters.

That is unacceptable to me. Can you conceptualize 219 a day? How about 6570 per month, and over 80,000 a year? Imagine a bin with 219 collars left at the end of each day, only to empty it and start over. And at an average cost of $400-$500 to get each pet rescued vaccinated, spayed/neutered, healthy and ready for a new home, the Atlanta animal welfare community needs $40,000,000 a year, just to get those pets ready for a new home (not to mention the maintenance costs of pets who wait for months in rescue to get a new home). Sounds like a lot, doesn't it? It's actually only $7.50 per person in Atlanta. No kidding -- if every person in Atlanta donated $7.50, we could raise enough money to get 80,000 homeless pets ready for adoption.

Unfortunately, we did not raise $40 million at our event.

So, what do we do? Is 80,000 pets and $40 million more than we can manage? And if the answer is yes, it's more than we can manage, then what?

I have often heard colleagues in animal welfare say, "there are fates worth than death." We see so much, too much, in our work to help homeless pets. We hear gruesome tales of cruelty and neglect, and more often, infuriating tales of irresponsibility, stupidity and lack of compassion.

Because of what we see on a daily basis, it's often too easy to forget that most people, most of you reading this, care as much as we do. You love your pets unconditionally, you provide the best for your pets, and you would spare nothing to keep them happy and healthy. And more often than not, you share our concern for homeless pets, and often want to be part of the solution.

Nathan Winograd is a leading figure in the animal welfare movement. While I don't always agree with all of his positions, he is always thoughtful and though-provoking. His recent blog entry, The Fallacy of “Fates Worse Than Death,” has made me stop and review my own core beliefs once again. In fact, there isn't a fate worse than death, because there is no salvation or rehabilitation from death. If a pet is dead, it's over. We have failed that living creature in the most offensive and cruel way possible.

What we need to do is stop allowing those other fates that often seem worse than death. If we consider abandonment, starvation and abuse as so cruel that death might be a relief, then it is up to us, as a compassionate community, to stop those things.

If a dog in your neighborhood is chained behind a house and is thrown scraps every few days, don't mutter to yourself that the dog might be better off dead. Do something.

If a cat in your neighborhood has been thrown outside, and the neighborhood children are constantly throwing rocks at it, don't mutter to yourself that the cat might be better off dead. Do something.

If you see pictures of pets in shelters, waiting for their "hold" periods to end, only to die, don't mutter to yourself that those pets might be better off dead. Do something.

219 pets will die in Atlanta shelters today. Which one will you help save?